Had a job last year where the owner insisted on a tile base—looked great for about six months, then the grout started cracking and leaking. Ended up tearing it out and putting in a plastic one anyway. Anyone tried those solid surface bases? Wondering if they hold up better or just as much hassle.
- Tile bases look awesome, but man, the maintenance is a pain. Grout just doesn’t like to stay put, especially if the subfloor isn’t perfect.
- Solid surface bases (like those Corian-type ones) are kind of the middle ground. They’re heavier than plastic, but you don’t have to worry about grout lines at all.
- I’ve demo’d a couple that were over ten years old and still going strong—just a few scratches, nothing major.
- They’re not as cheap as plastic, but you’re not redoing the job in a year either.
- Only real hassle is they’re heavy to move around. Bring a buddy or eat your Wheaties...
I hear you on the grout—nothing like spending a weekend scrubbing and sealing just to have it crack again a few months later. Solid surface bases are definitely less drama, but man, moving those things is a workout. I’ve seen some folks swear by the newer composite bases too—supposedly lighter than Corian but still tough. Has anyone actually tried one of those long-term? I’m curious if they hold up or just end up looking dingy after a couple years.
Plastic Vs. Tile-Ready Shower Bases: Which One's Less Hassle?
Yeah, grout’s a pain—no argument there. I’ve put in a few of those composite bases lately. They’re lighter, sure, but I’m still not convinced on long-term durability. Seen a couple get scratched up pretty quick. Not as bad as the old fiberglass, but not bulletproof either. If you’re rough on your showers, I’d still lean solid surface, even if it’s a beast to move.
Plastic Vs. Tile-Ready Shower Bases: Which One's Less Hassle?
I hear you on the scratched-up composite bases. First time I helped install one, I thought it was gonna be a breeze—lightweight, easy to maneuver. But then my buddy dropped a wrench and left a nice gouge right in the corner. Tile-ready ones are heavier for sure, but at least you don’t have to worry about them getting dinged up as easily. Still, I’m not a fan of dealing with grout either... always seems to find a way to crack or get grimy no matter how careful you are.