How do you usually tackle installing a new drain - DIY or call in a pro?

- Been called out more than once for “quick fixes” that turned into bigger messes.
- Push-to-connects are fine for emergencies, but I’ve seen them leak after a few months - especially if the pipe isn’t cut square.
- Plumber’s tape is good, but too much can actually crack plastic threads. Seen it happen.
- DIY with YouTube works for some, but I’ve had to fix a lot of “YouTube specials”... sometimes it’s worth just getting it done right the first time.
- Towels are great, but a bucket under the trap saves a lot more cleanup.

Honestly, I’ve patched up more “quick fix” drains than I can count - usually after a push-to-connect fitting starts weeping behind the cabinet. I’d add: always dry-fit the pieces first, and double-check for burrs on the pipe ends. Even a tiny nick can cause headaches later. And yeah, that bucket trick under the trap? Lifesaver. Towels just don’t cut it when someone forgets to empty the sink first...

That bucket trick has saved my butt more times than I care to admit. I’m with you on the dry-fit and burr check - people skip that step, then wonder why there’s a slow leak down the line. But honestly, I’m not sold on push-to-connect for drains at all. They’re fine for a quick patch, but if you want it to last, glue and primer or even a good old compression fitting just holds up better. Seen too many “quick fixes” turn into weekend projects...

I hear you on the push-to-connect stuff - honestly, I’ve never fully trusted them for anything that’s supposed to be permanent. Maybe it’s just my luck, but every time I’ve tried one on a drain, it’s felt a little too “temporary fix” for my taste. Glue and primer might take longer, but at least I know it’s not going anywhere if I do it right. Compression fittings are decent too, especially if you need to take things apart later.

That said, I get the appeal of quick fixes when you’re in a pinch or if you’re renting and don’t want to invest a ton. But for my own place? I’d rather spend an extra hour and not worry about crawling under the sink again next month.

Curious - has anyone actually had a push-to-connect fitting last more than a couple years on a drain? Or is it just me being overly cautious?

every time I’ve tried one on a drain, it’s felt a little too “temporary fix” for my taste.

Yeah, I get that. I’ve had the same feeling - like, sure, it clicks in, but will it hold up if someone bumps the pipe or if things shift a bit? For me, glue and primer just give that peace of mind. Maybe push-to-connect is fine for a quick patch, but for a main drain? I’d rather not risk it. You’re not being overly cautious at all.