Sometimes it’s just a $2 fix instead of a deep clean.
Honestly, I’m always a bit skeptical it’s *just* the washer, but you’re right—it happens more than folks think. Did you check if the threads on the pipe or showerhead were stripped at all? Sometimes even with a new gasket, if those are worn out, you’ll still get that wild spray.
Had a similar mess once—thought it was just the washer too, but after swapping that out, the spray was still wild. Turned out the threads on the arm were chewed up from years of over-tightening. Ended up wrapping ‘em in plumber’s tape and tightening it gently, which actually did the trick. Sometimes it’s not just one thing... gotta check all the little details or you’ll be chasing leaks forever.
Funny thing, I’ve seen folks go down the thread-and-tape rabbit hole, but sometimes it’s not even the threads or the washer. Had a job last winter where the spray was all over the place—looked like a busted fire hydrant. Turned out the faceplate of the showerhead was caked with mineral buildup, so the water was hitting those little blockages and shooting sideways. Gave it a soak in vinegar, scrubbed it out, and it was back to normal.
I get the temptation to wrap everything in plumber’s tape (I’ve done it myself plenty), but if the threads are really chewed up, that’s just a band-aid. Eventually, you might need to replace the whole arm. Sometimes it’s the simple stuff—gunked-up holes, cracked plastic, or even a loose swivel joint. Just goes to show, chasing leaks can be a wild goose chase if you don’t look at the obvious bits first.
Had a tenant once swear up and down it was “definitely a plumbing leak,” but all it needed was a good soak and scrub like you said. Hard water’s a silent troublemaker. I always check for buildup or cracks first—saves a lot of hassle (and water damage).
Hard water really does sneak up on you. I’ve seen showerheads look like they’re about to fall apart, but a vinegar soak brings them right back. You’re spot on—checking for buildup first saves a ton of time and money. Sometimes folks jump to “leak” way too fast when it’s just mineral gunk messing with the spray. Good call catching it early.