Totally agree on brass fittings holding up better in the long run. I've lost count of how many cracked plastic connectors I've replaced over the years—sometimes the savings just aren't worth it when you're dealing with leaks behind drywall. Good call on mentioning the PTFE tape trick, too. It's one of those little things DIYers often overlook, but it makes life so much easier down the road. Sounds like you've learned a few plumbing lessons the hard way, just like me...
Great points on brass fittings and PTFE tape—definitely helpful tips for someone new to plumbing like me. But just to throw in a slightly different perspective:
- I've actually had decent luck with some higher-quality plastic connectors (PEX fittings specifically). Maybe it's because I haven't had them long enough yet, but they're holding up surprisingly well so far.
- I get the appeal of brass, especially durability-wise, but the cost difference can be pretty steep when you're doing a whole bathroom reno. For a first-time homeowner like me, saving a bit here and there does add up.
- Totally agree though, cheap plastic is asking for trouble. Learned that lesson fast after my first leak behind drywall—never again...
- Also, quick note on PTFE tape: great stuff, but I've found pipe dope (thread sealant) to be even easier sometimes, especially in tight spaces. Less fiddly and messy fingers aside, seems to seal just as well.
- Curious if anyone else has tried both and prefers one over the other? I'm still experimenting and learning as I go.
Either way, appreciate all the insights here—makes tackling this DIY bathroom project a lot less intimidating...
Gotta say, your experience with PEX fittings matches mine pretty closely. I've been plumbing professionally for years now, and while brass is the gold standard (pun intended), good-quality plastic connectors have really come a long way. I redid my own bathroom about two years ago using mostly PEX fittings—partly to test them out, partly because I'm cheap—and they're still going strong. Knock on wood...
Funny you mention pipe dope vs PTFE tape. I started out strictly tape-only because that's how I learned from the old-timers, but once I tried pipe dope, I never really went back. Had a particularly nasty job replacing a faucet under a cramped vanity—picture me twisted like a pretzel, cursing quietly (okay, loudly)—and pipe dope saved my sanity. Easier to apply, less fiddling around, and fewer leaks.
That said, I still keep PTFE tape handy for quick fixes or threads that seem a bit sketchy. Sometimes it's just habit, sometimes convenience. But hey, whatever keeps water off your floors and drywall intact is a win in my book...
"Funny you mention pipe dope vs PTFE tape. I started out strictly tape-only because that's how I learned from the old-timers, but once I tried pipe dope, I never really went back."
Interesting, I didn't even know pipe dope was a thing until recently. Always just grabbed PTFE tape because it was cheap and seemed straightforward. Might give the dope a shot next time though—especially if it's easier in tight spaces. Any particular brand you'd recommend for someone on a budget?
Might give the dope a shot next time though—especially if it's easier in tight spaces. Any particular brand you'd recommend for someone on a budget?
I've used both extensively, and honestly, pipe dope is a lifesaver in cramped spots. Tape can be fiddly when you're wedged under a sink. Rectorseal No. 5 is reliable and budget-friendly—never had issues with leaks or drying out. Worth a try if you're switching over.
