Plastic threads are definitely one of those things that make me nervous too, especially in rentals where you never know how careful the next person will be. I’ve had a couple of jobs where someone overtightened and the whole trap just cracked—always seems to happen late at night, right? I actually started using a dab of plumber’s grease on the threads. It helps them seat better and makes it easier to undo later without binding or stripping. Not sure if everyone does that, but it’s saved me a few headaches.
Funny thing about off-center sinks: I once had to connect a drain that was almost two inches off from the wall stub. Ended up with this Frankenstein setup of flexible couplers and elbows... looked ridiculous but held up fine. Still, I always worry about leaks down the line, especially if someone bumps it while storing stuff under the sink. Ever tried using metal traps instead? They’re less forgiving for alignment but seem sturdier for threads—just not as easy to tweak if things aren’t lined up perfectly.
Metal traps are definitely sturdier, but like you said, they’re not forgiving at all if things aren’t lined up just right. I tried one under my kitchen sink and ended up fighting with it for an hour before giving up and going back to plastic.
“Ended up with this Frankenstein setup of flexible couplers and elbows... looked ridiculous but held up fine.”
Honestly, I’ve done the same thing—those flex couplers are lifesavers when the drain’s way off. My only worry is they seem like a temporary fix, especially if you’re storing heavy cleaners under there. I’ve started using pipe straps to secure everything so it doesn’t shift if someone bumps it. Not perfect, but it helps.
Pipe straps definitely help, but I’ve noticed if the flex couplers aren’t cut to the right length, they can sag over time—especially with heavier bottles shifting around underneath. Sometimes I’ll add a little foam padding between the pipe and cabinet wall just to keep things from rattling. Not the prettiest solution, but it keeps leaks at bay.
