Pipe Lining Isn’t Always the Silver Bullet
- Gotta admit, pipe lining sounds great on paper—less mess, less yard carnage, and you’re not digging up your prized rose bushes. But here’s the thing: it’s not always a slam dunk. If your pipes are already Swiss cheese, lining can end up like putting a Band-Aid on a leaky garden hose. Sometimes the roots have done so much damage, the liner doesn’t have much to grab onto, and you’re back to square one.
- Copper sulfate… yeah, it’s the old-school trick. Works for a while, but I’ve seen folks get a little too enthusiastic with it. Next thing you know, you’ve got blue stains in the basement and the local frogs are giving you dirty looks. Not exactly eco-friendly, and if you’ve got a septic system, it can mess with the good bacteria in there.
- PVC replacement is the gold standard, no doubt. But if you’re in one of those “dig and destroy” neighborhoods, I get the hesitation. Sometimes you just can’t face the thought of turning your front yard into a construction zone for a week.
- Here’s a curveball—have you ever tried regular mechanical root cutting? Not glamorous, but a good old-fashioned rooter every year or two can keep things flowing without chemicals or liners. I’ve got a client who treats it like spring cleaning: roots get a trim, pipes stay happy, and no blue sludge in sight.
- One last thing—if you’re dealing with monster trees (looking at you, silver maples), sometimes the only real fix is to say goodbye to the tree. Not popular, but neither is a flooded basement.
Long story short, lining works for a lot of folks, but it’s not a miracle cure. Sometimes a mix of old and new school is the way to go. And if all else fails, maybe just plant cacti next time…
I get the hesitation about pipe lining, but I’ve actually had better luck with it than expected.
Maybe it depends on how bad the damage is? My plumber scoped mine first and said the structure was still decent, so lining worked out. I’m not a fan of chopping down trees unless there’s no other option—feels a bit drastic. Anyone else had lining last more than a few years?“If your pipes are already Swiss cheese, lining can end up like putting a Band-Aid on a leaky garden hose.”
I get the appeal of lining, especially if you want to avoid tearing up the yard or losing a tree. Still, I’m a bit wary if the pipes are already pretty compromised. My neighbor went the lining route and it worked for a while, but after about four years, roots found their way back in. Maybe it’s just luck of the draw, but I’d rather play it safe and replace sections if there’s major damage. Not cheap, but less stress down the line...
I hear you on wanting to avoid future headaches, but lining can actually be a solid fix if the pipe’s structure isn’t too far gone. I’ve seen it hold up 10+ years when done right, especially if the roots are cut back and the liner bonds well. Sometimes folks skip the root removal step or don’t address the source, and that’s when problems sneak back in. Full replacement is definitely best for pipes that are collapsing or missing chunks, but for minor to moderate cracks, lining can buy a lot of time without wrecking your landscaping. Just gotta weigh how bad the damage is before deciding.
Totally agree that lining’s a real lifesaver if your pipes aren’t basically Swiss cheese. I actually went the lining route last fall—my wallet is still grateful.
-
“Sometimes folks skip the root removal step or don’t address the source, and that’s when problems sneak back in.”
Yep, learned that the hard way. Root removal is NOT optional. My plumber showed me what looked like a spaghetti monster in there...
- If you’re on a budget (like me, after buying this house), lining buys time and keeps the yard looking decent.
- Only thing I’d add—get a camera inspection first. I almost skipped it but turns out what I thought was a “little crack” was actually more like a pothole.
Anyway, here’s hoping the roots don’t plot their next comeback anytime soon.
