I’ve actually tried one of those spray-on vapor barriers in my crawlspace a couple years back. Honestly, I wasn’t super impressed. It looked fine at first, but after a cold snap and some heavy rain, I noticed a few damp spots creeping in around the seams. Maybe it was installer error, maybe just not as foolproof as the old 6-mil poly. Like you said—
Hard to argue with that when you’ve seen what moisture can do over time.“it’s cheap insurance and saves headaches later.”
I hear you on the spray-on stuff. Tried it once in a rental—looked good at first, but didn’t hold up to a wet winter. Like you said:
“it’s cheap insurance and saves headaches later.”
- 6-mil poly is still my go-to. It’s simple, easy to patch, and you can see what’s going on underneath.
- I always tape the seams and run it up the walls a bit—makes a difference.
- Moisture sneaks in anywhere it can. If you’ve got older pipes down there, that dampness just speeds up corrosion.
Honestly, sometimes old-school methods just work better.
I’m with you on the old-school approach—sometimes the simplest fix is the most reliable. I’ve had a few clients who went all-in on that spray-on barrier, thinking it’d be a one-and-done solution. Looked fine until the first heavy rain, then we were back to square one with damp crawlspaces and rust stains creeping up the pipes.
“Moisture sneaks in anywhere it can. If you’ve got older pipes down there, that dampness just speeds up corrosion.”
Couldn’t agree more. I’ve seen galvanized lines that were borderline salvageable get ruined in just a couple seasons because someone skipped proper vapor barrier and seam taping. The 6-mil poly isn’t glamorous, but you can spot leaks or condensation before it turns into a bigger mess. And if you ever need to patch or reroute something, you’re not fighting through some mystery goop.
I do wish more folks would take the time to run that poly up the wall a foot or so—makes a world of difference for keeping things dry. It’s not flashy, but neither is having to replace half your plumbing because of avoidable rust.
Title: Making sure your home’s pipes are up to code—how I do it
You nailed it with the “mystery goop” bit. I’ve had to dig through that stuff more times than I care to remember, and it’s always a mess—never as easy as just lifting a sheet of poly and getting right to the problem. Folks love a quick fix until it bites them later.
I get why people want the spray-on stuff. It looks high-tech, and the sales pitch is always “set it and forget it.” But water finds a way, especially in crawlspaces that already have a few decades on them. I’ve seen those fancy barriers peel up or crack after one good freeze-thaw cycle, and then you’re right back to puddles and rusted fittings. Not fun.
Running the poly up the wall is one of those details that gets skipped way too often. It’s not glamorous, like you said, but it’s a lifesaver. I’ve even seen people use duct tape instead of proper seam tape—looks fine for about a month, then you get that musty smell and realize you’ve got a science experiment brewing under your house.
One thing I’ll add—sometimes folks get so focused on the vapor barrier that they forget about airflow. I’m not saying you want a wind tunnel down there, but sealing everything up tight without any ventilation can turn the place into a sauna. That’s when you start seeing condensation on cold water lines, even if the ground’s dry.
Anyway, I’m with you on keeping things simple and visible. Give me 6-mil poly, some decent tape, and a flashlight over any miracle spray or “guaranteed” coating. At least then you know what you’re working with... and you don’t have to spend half an hour scraping gunk off your boots.
“I’ve even seen people use duct tape instead of proper seam tape—looks fine for about a month, then you get that musty smell and realize you’ve got a science experiment brewing under your house.”
Couldn’t agree more on the duct tape. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve crawled under a place and found seams “sealed” with whatever was handy—duct tape, packing tape, even masking tape once. It never holds up to moisture or temperature swings. If you’re going to do it, just spend the extra few bucks on real vapor barrier tape. Saves a lot of headaches.
A couple things I’d add:
- Pipe insulation gets overlooked in crawlspaces. Even if you’ve got a good vapor barrier and some airflow, cold snaps can still freeze pipes if they’re not wrapped right. I always check for gaps or spots where insulation’s slipped off.
- On ventilation: I see people block every vent thinking it’ll keep things dry, but like you said, that just traps humidity. I usually recommend adjustable vents—close them up in winter, open them back up when it warms up.
- About the “miracle” coatings—some of those products have their place (like sealing foundation cracks), but for broad coverage under a house? Not worth the risk or cost in my experience.
One thing I do differently: I run the poly at least 6 inches up the wall and anchor it with furring strips if possible. Tape alone sometimes peels after a year or two, especially if there’s any movement or critters poking around.
And yeah, nothing beats being able to see what’s going on down there. If there’s a leak or condensation issue, you want to spot it before it turns into rot or mold. The more complicated the setup, the harder it is to troubleshoot later.
Funny story—last winter I got called out because someone’s “permanent” spray-on barrier had started flaking off in sheets after a cold snap. Ended up spending twice as long cleaning up as I would’ve just laying new poly from scratch.
Simple materials, done right, beat fancy shortcuts every time... at least in my book.
