Honestly, I’ve had the same debate with myself—those lightweight fixtures always seem like a good idea until you’re tightening something and it feels like it might snap. My go-to is to check the weight in hand (not super scientific, but heavier usually means more metal inside). If you can, peek under the sink at showrooms; sometimes you can spot the brass bits versus all plastic. Also, I keep a stash of spare washers and O-rings because it’s way easier to swap those than deal with a full replacement... Learned that after one too many leaky handles.
Weight’s a decent indicator, but I’ve seen some surprisingly sturdy composite fixtures lately—don’t write them off just because they’re light. That said, brass internals are still my preference for anything that gets daily use. Keeping extra washers on hand is a lifesaver... I’ve patched up more than a few “emergencies” with just those and a bit of plumber’s grease. Sometimes it’s the little things that save you from a weekend plumbing disaster.
Brass internals are tough to beat for longevity, especially if you’re dealing with hard water. I’ve had a few composite fixtures hold up better than expected, but I still lean toward metal for anything that gets a lot of use. Keeping a stash of washers and a tube of plumber’s grease in the toolbox has saved me more times than I can count—funny how the smallest parts make the biggest difference when something starts leaking at 9pm on a Sunday...
I get where you’re coming from about brass—my old place had those, and they lasted forever even with our mineral-heavy water. But I’ve actually switched to a couple of composite fixtures recently because I was trying to cut down on metal use and see if there’s less environmental impact. Mixed results so far… One bathroom faucet’s been fine, but the kitchen tap needed a new washer after a year. Like you said,
—totally true! Ever tried any of the “eco” labeled fixtures? I’m curious if they really hold up or if it’s just marketing.“the smallest parts make the biggest difference when something starts leaking at 9pm on a Sunday...”
I hear you on the composite fixtures—tried a couple myself, and it’s really hit or miss. The “eco” ones I’ve worked with usually have decent flow restrictors, but sometimes the internal parts (like washers or cartridges) just don’t last as long as the old-school brass. If you go that route, I’d suggest keeping a spare washer kit handy. Nothing worse than scrambling for parts when everything’s closed... Also, check if the eco label means actual water savings or just recycled materials—sometimes it’s more marketing than substance.
