I totally get where you’re coming from—tossing out an ice maker just feels wasteful, especially when it’s usually just a small part that fails. I’ve actually tried refurbishing one before, swapping out the motor and cleaning up the mold. It took some patience (and a few YouTube tutorials), but it worked for another year or so. Not every part is easy to source, though, and sometimes the cost adds up close to a new unit. Still, if you’re handy and don’t mind tinkering, it’s worth a shot before heading straight to replacement.
I hear you on the repair vs. replace debate. I tried fixing ours last year—just needed a new water inlet valve, which ran me about $40. Took me an afternoon and a couple of scraped knuckles, but it got the job done. That said, I always get a bit nervous messing with anything electrical or water-related in the fridge... One small leak and you’ve got bigger problems. Sometimes I wonder if paying a pro is worth the peace of mind, even if it’s more upfront.
$40 for a valve and a couple of knuckle scrapes isn’t bad at all. Honestly, I’ve had tenants call me for ice maker issues and sometimes I’ll try to tackle it myself—usually ends up with me on YouTube and swearing at the back of the fridge. One time I thought I fixed it, but nope, just managed to make a tiny leak that dripped down behind the wall... fun times. Paying a pro stings up front, but it’s less stress (and drywall repair) in the long run, at least for me. Ever tried fixing one with tenants breathing down your neck? That’s when you really start questioning your life choices.
Man, I’ve been there—ice maker repairs always seem simple until you’re wedged behind the fridge, sweating and cursing. I’ve had leaks too, and honestly, water damage is a nightmare compared to just paying someone $100 or so. Ever try finding the shutoff valve when you’re already panicking? Not worth the headache in my book.
- Couldn’t agree more about the shutoff valve panic—seen it too many times.
- Water damage from a tiny leak can end up costing way more than a basic service call.
- Honestly, unless you’re super comfortable with plumbing and have time to troubleshoot, just paying the $100-$150 is usually worth it.
- One thing I’d add: check the supply line for kinks or cracks while you’re back there. Sometimes it’s not even the ice maker, but that cheap plastic tubing causing all the trouble.
- If you do DIY, have towels and a bucket ready... trust me, you’ll need them.
