Plumbing discussions and local services.

anyone tried sustainable plumbing upgrades at home?

485 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

einferno43

I've installed a few greywater systems for people, and you're right, they're generally easier to maintain than rainwater tanks. The key is making sure you're using biodegradable soaps and detergents - otherwise, you could end up harming your plants or clogging the pipes over time. Also, it's good practice to install a simple filter or mesh screen at the inlet to catch lint or hair from showers and laundry water. It takes just a minute to clean once in a while and saves you headaches later on.

Rainwater tanks can be great too, but yeah... size matters. Smaller tanks do reduce algae issues somewhat, but placement is equally important. Keeping your tank shaded or even partially underground helps prevent algae growth since sunlight encourages it. I've also seen people use UV sterilizers or simple chlorine tablets occasionally to keep things clear without too much fuss.

And pineapple pizza? That's one plumbing problem I'm not touching with a ten-foot wrench...


Reply
jakegardener

I've been considering a greywater setup myself, but I'm still a bit hesitant about the biodegradable soap thing. Do you find that switching to these eco-friendly detergents affects how well your clothes or dishes actually get cleaned? I've tried a couple of those natural laundry soaps before, and honestly, they didn't seem to work as well - maybe I just picked the wrong brands?

Also, about rainwater tanks... does anyone know if partially burying them causes any issues with maintenance or durability long-term? Like, do you need special tanks for underground installation, or can you just sink a regular tank halfway down without problems?

And pineapple pizza debates aside (though I have strong feelings there too...), how much does adding UV sterilizers or chlorine tablets impact the water's taste or safety for garden use? Seems like it might defeat the purpose of collecting rainwater if you're adding chemicals back in...?


Reply
jerrym56

I've had a greywater setup for about two years now, and yeah, switching detergents was a bit of trial and error. Some eco-friendly brands just don't cut it, especially with greasy dishes or heavily stained clothes. I've found that plant-based detergents with citrus enzymes seem to work best - at least for me.

About rain tanks, I partially buried a regular tank initially, and it warped slightly after a year... ended up replacing it with one specifically designed for underground use. Lesson learned there.

As for UV sterilizers, they don't affect taste at all, unlike chlorine tablets, which definitely leave a noticeable chemical taste. For garden use, UV is probably your best bet if you're concerned about chemicals.


Reply
fishing778

Totally agree on the citrus enzyme detergents, they've been a lifesaver for greasy pans. Haven't tried UV sterilizers yet, but good to know they don't mess with taste... chlorine tabs always made my water taste like a swimming pool. Might have to look into UV now.


Reply
shadowpianist

I've been using a UV sterilizer for about six months now, and honestly, it's been a solid investment. Like you mentioned, chlorine tabs always left that weird aftertaste - definitely not ideal for drinking water. The UV setup was pretty straightforward, though it did take some careful planning to position it properly under the sink. Once installed though, zero taste issues and maintenance has been minimal... just replacing the bulb annually. If you're already liking enzyme detergents, you'll probably appreciate the simplicity and effectiveness of UV sterilization too.


Reply
sonicdiver

"Once installed though, zero taste issues and maintenance has been minimal... just replacing the bulb annually."

Interesting, didn't realize UV sterilizers were that low-maintenance. Did you notice any difference in your electricity bill after installing it? Curious if it's energy-efficient enough to justify long-term use.


Reply
math_pat

The electricity cost depends on the unit's wattage and running time, so the model number would help. Taste won't tell you whether the UV treatment is doing its job.

I'd budget for the whole maintenance schedule, including the lamp, quartz sleeve and any prefilters, rather than just a yearly bulb. Check the system's indicators and testing requirements too. UV is aimed at microbes; it doesn't remove chemical contaminants.


Reply
poetry_emily

For straightforward water savings, I'd compare suitable low-flow fixtures before taking on greywater recycling. Showerhead performance varies, so the flow rating and compatibility with the shower valve matter.

Greywater is a bigger project: local rules, where the water can go and ongoing maintenance all need checking before anything is rerouted. Even a laundry-to-landscape setup needs a proper plan. Has anyone kept one running for several years, and what upkeep turned out to be the most work?


Reply
swimmer429606

Low-flow fixtures are definitely worth it, but I'd be cautious about jumping into greywater recycling without thorough research. I've seen DIY setups cause more trouble than they're worth - clogged filters, odors, even code violations. If you're serious about it, maybe talk to someone who's had a system running for a few years to get the real scoop on maintenance and hidden costs. Has anyone dealt with unexpected issues after installing sustainable plumbing upgrades?


Reply
mthompson87

We put in low-flow showerheads and faucets last year - no regrets there, water bill dropped noticeably. But I've been curious about composting toilets. Heard mixed things: some say they're odorless and easy, others complain about maintenance nightmares and weird smells sneaking up after a while... Wondering if anyone's actually lived with one long-term and can share the real deal on upkeep and practicality?


Reply
donnarobinson593

Installed a few composting toilets over the years, and I've seen the good, the bad, and the ugly. Honestly, when they're set up right and maintained properly, they're pretty decent - odorless and straightforward. But here's the catch: maintenance is key. If you're someone who tends to procrastinate or skip routine upkeep, things can get messy (and smelly) fast.

Had a client who swore by theirs for years, but they were meticulous about emptying and turning the compost regularly. Another family I worked with let things slide a bit, and let's just say their bathroom wasn't exactly guest-friendly after a while...

Bottom line: if you're committed to regular maintenance and don't mind getting hands-on occasionally, composting toilets can be great. But if you're looking for something you can install and forget about, stick with your low-flow fixtures and maybe look into greywater recycling instead.


Reply
cheryl_wanderer

Haha, your post made me chuckle - I've definitely seen (and smelled) what happens when folks slack on compost toilet upkeep. Had one client who proudly showed off his setup, but when I opened the lid... let's just say it was less compost and more science experiment. Totally agree though, with a bit of elbow grease and consistency, these systems can be pretty impressive. Good on you for pointing out the reality check!


Reply
mochathinker986

I've seen compost toilets done right, but honestly they're not for everyone. Maintenance aside, there's still the issue of guest comfort and convenience. Ever had visitors freak out when you explain how it works? I mean, sustainable plumbing is great, but maybe greywater recycling or low-flow fixtures are easier wins for most people... less hassle and fewer awkward conversations.


Reply
electronics709

You're spot on about guest comfort - I've had similar experiences explaining our greywater system. People can be hesitant at first, but once they see it's safe and sanitary, they usually come around. Small steps like low-flow fixtures definitely make sustainability more approachable for most households.


Reply
dobby_campbell

Totally agree on low-flow fixtures - huge impact with minimal hassle. A couple other things I've noticed:

- Tankless water heaters save energy and space, but upfront costs can be steep.
- Rainwater harvesting systems are great, though maintenance can be tricky depending on your climate.

Definitely worth weighing pros and cons carefully...


Reply
waffleswanderer786

Tankless heaters are great in theory, but has anyone else had the "cold sandwich" experience? You know, hot water... then suddenly cold... then hot again? Happened to me mid-shower once - talk about a rude awakening. 😂

Rainwater harvesting sounded awesome too, until I realized my area gets either drought or monsoon-level rain, nothing in between. Tried setting up a basic barrel system, and let's just say my DIY skills were seriously tested. Overflow everywhere, mosquitoes thinking I'd built them a luxury resort... total mess.

Low-flow fixtures though - those were a win. Swapped out showerheads and faucets last year, and honestly didn't even notice the difference in water pressure. My water bill sure did, though.

Anyone else have plumbing upgrades that seemed genius at first but ended up being more comedy than eco-friendly?


Reply
coffee546

Had the same tankless heater issue at first - turns out it was undersized for our house. Upgraded to a bigger unit, problem solved. Rain barrels though...yeah, still figuring that one out. Mosquitoes are loving my eco-friendly intentions way too much.


Reply
drobinson94

I had a similar mosquito issue with my rain barrels. Thought I was doing the right thing by capturing rainwater, but it quickly turned into a mosquito breeding paradise. Have you tried those mosquito dunks yet? They're basically little disks that float in the water and contain a bacteria harmless to people and pets but deadly for mosquito larvae. Worked pretty well for me.

As for tankless water heaters, yeah, sizing is key. I lucked out because the plumber who installed mine made sure to calculate our household's peak demand. No cold showers yet, so fingers crossed it stays that way! I'm curious though - did anyone here try greywater systems yet? I've been looking into them as another sustainable plumbing upgrade, but I'm a bit hesitant. Seems like they could be complicated to set up properly and safely...especially with local codes being all over the place.

Also wondering about maintenance - does anyone find that these sustainable plumbing upgrades end up requiring more upkeep or troubleshooting than traditional setups? I love the idea of going greener, but practicality is important too.


Reply
baking_steven

I totally get what you're saying about the mosquitoes - I learned that lesson the hard way too. Those dunks were a lifesaver for me as well, but I also found that adding some fine mesh screening over the openings of my rain barrels helped keep mosquitoes from laying eggs in the first place. It's a bit of extra work initially, but maintenance afterward is pretty minimal.

Regarding greywater systems, I've been researching them myself because I love the idea of reusing water from showers or laundry. But honestly...the complexity and local code restrictions have put me off a bit too. My neighbor installed one recently and mentioned it took him months to get approval from the city. He also said cleaning filters regularly became part of his routine, more than he initially expected.

On the plus side, he's definitely saving water and feels good about it - but it's not exactly "set it and forget it." So yeah, sustainable plumbing upgrades can be rewarding but do seem to come with their own quirks and upkeep. Guess it's all about finding your comfort zone between eco-friendly goals and practicality.


Reply
rain_campbell

Mesh screening is definitely a solid idea - I've seen it work well for clients who collect rainwater. Greywater systems, though...they're great in theory, but I've noticed they often become more hassle than homeowners anticipate. Between the permits, inspections, and ongoing maintenance, it's not always practical for everyone. Has anyone here tried simpler alternatives, like low-flow fixtures or dual-flush toilets? Curious how those stack up in terms of ease and actual water savings.


Reply

Find a local plumber.

Loading local plumbers…

Scroll to Top