Yeah, seen this happen more times than I can count. Lining can be okay in certain situations, but it's never a guaranteed fix—especially if the original pipe's already compromised or badly damaged. Usually, you're just buying yourself a little extra time. Always better off biting the bullet and doing the full replacement from the start... saves money and headaches in the long run.
I get where you're coming from, but honestly, full replacements aren't always the best route either. Had a similar issue a couple years back—went for the full replacement thinking it'd solve everything, but ended up with a torn-up yard and way more hassle than expected. Sometimes lining can actually be a decent middle-ground solution, especially if you're trying to minimize environmental impact or disruption. Not saying it's perfect, but it's worth considering before you dive into a full-on excavation job...
"Sometimes lining can actually be a decent middle-ground solution, especially if you're trying to minimize environmental impact or disruption."
Totally agree with this. A couple years back, I had the dreaded basement backup—right before hosting Thanksgiving dinner, no less. Talk about timing... Anyway, after some frantic research (and a few panicked phone calls), I decided to give lining a shot instead of a full replacement. Honestly, it was mostly because my wallet was already crying at the thought of excavation costs.
Surprisingly, the lining route turned out pretty well. No torn-up lawn, no heavy machinery parked in my driveway for days on end. Sure, it's not a miracle cure-all, but it bought me peace of mind without completely emptying my savings. Plus, my grass stayed intact—my neighbors still envy my lawn (little do they know it's pure luck).
All I'm saying is, don't discount lining too quickly. It might save you some headaches—and cash—in the long run.
Totally agree with this.
Interesting to hear lining worked out for you. I've been considering it myself, mostly because I'm worried about the environmental impact of excavation—heavy machinery, disturbed soil, runoff issues... Did you notice any downsides or limitations since having it done? I'm curious if it's a long-term fix or more of a temporary band-aid solution.
I've been thinking about lining too, but I'm still on the fence. My neighbor had theirs lined about two years ago, and it seemed great at first, but recently they've mentioned some slow draining again. Not sure if that's typical or just bad luck...? I'm leaning toward excavation despite the mess—maybe short-term pain for long-term gain. Has anyone else noticed lining losing effectiveness over time, or is it usually pretty solid?
