Press-fits definitely have their place, especially in tight spots or emergency repairs. I had a similar midnight plumbing adventure last year—my hot water line sprung a leak behind the kitchen cabinets. No way was I pulling everything apart to solder at 2 AM, so I grabbed a couple of SharkBite fittings from my toolbox. Quick trim, deburr, push-fit, and done. Took maybe 15 mins total.
But for planned projects, I still lean towards soldering. It's not just peace of mind—it's also cost. Press fittings can add up fast if you're doing more extensive work. For anyone new to soldering, here's a quick tip: clean your fittings thoroughly with emery cloth, apply flux evenly (not too much!), heat the joint uniformly until the flux bubbles slightly, then touch the solder to the opposite side of the flame. It'll wick right in perfectly every time.
Both methods have their strengths...just depends on your situation and budget, really.
"Both methods have their strengths...just depends on your situation and budget, really."
Couldn't agree more. I had a similar debate when I redid my bathroom plumbing last spring. Initially, press-fits seemed tempting for convenience, but the eco-conscious side of me worried about long-term durability and waste. Ended up soldering most joints—felt good knowing they'd last decades without needing replacements. Still, press-fits saved me big time when I accidentally nicked a pipe behind the vanity... quick fix and no water wasted overnight. Like you said, it's all situational.
Yeah, soldering definitely feels more solid long-term. But honestly, press-fits saved my sanity when I was knee-deep in boiler drama last winter—no leaks yet, fingers crossed. Sometimes convenience wins out over perfection, y'know?
Press-fits, huh? Can't deny they're handy in a pinch, but you trust 'em long-term under boiler pressure? Still, if it's holding up through winter chaos, you're probably good... fingers crossed indeed.
Yeah, press-fits can definitely save your day when you're stuck, but long-term under boiler pressure... I'd be a bit cautious too. I've seen a couple hold up surprisingly well through some nasty winters, but I've also had to help replace one that started leaking after just a year. Not fun when it's freezing out and you're scrambling to fix it.
Personally, I prefer soldered joints for anything that's gonna see constant heat cycles and pressure changes. Sure, press-fits are quick and clean—no torch needed—but there's something reassuring about a properly sweated joint. Maybe I'm just overly cautious, but boilers aren't exactly forgiving if something goes wrong.
Still, if yours made it through the winter chaos without issues, that's a pretty good sign. Just keep an eye on it every now and then—especially when the seasons change and things expand or contract. Better safe than sorry...
