- Totally agree about the under-sink install not being as intimidating as it looks.
- The first time I did one, I was convinced I’d mess up the shutoff valve, but it was actually pretty straightforward.
- Countertop filters are definitely easier to set up, but yeah, they just take up space and look kinda clunky.
- One thing I noticed—under-sink filters usually last longer between cartridge changes, so less hassle in the long run.
- Only thing is, if your plumbing’s old, sometimes you run into weird fittings or leaks... but nothing a little plumber’s tape can’t fix.
- Honestly, once you get the hang of it, it’s way less stressful than it seems at first.
Did both types, and honestly, I’d rather deal with the under-sink one. First time was nerve-wracking but after that, it’s not a big deal. Countertop was faster to set up, but it just looked messy and always got in the way. Under-sink is out of sight, out of mind… plus, fewer filter changes means less money spent over time. Just had to buy a cheap wrench and some plumber’s tape—worth it.
First time was nerve-wracking but after that, it’s not a big deal.
I get where you’re coming from, but I’ve had more headaches with under-sink installs than I care to remember. Leaks, weird fittings, tenants calling because they can’t figure out the shutoff valve... it adds up. Countertop might look clunky, but if you’re dealing with rentals or frequent moves, it’s way less hassle. Just hook it up and you’re done—no crawling around with a flashlight and a wrench. For me, the “out of sight, out of mind” thing only works until there’s a drip under the cabinet.
I hear you on the leaks—nothing worse than finding a puddle under the sink days later. Still, I lean toward under-sink filters, especially if you’re planning to stay put for a while. Once you get past the initial install (which, yeah, can be awkward), you don’t have hoses draped over the counter or adapters that can get knocked loose. I always double-check fittings and use plumber’s tape just in case. Maybe it’s overkill, but I’d rather spend an extra half hour upfront than deal with water damage down the line.
Honestly, countertop filters are way less hassle for rentals or if you’re not handy. Under-sink ones can be a pain if you’ve got old plumbing or tight cabinets. I’ve seen tenants mess up installs and cause leaks anyway, even with tape. Sometimes simple is better.
