Notifications
Clear all

Rusty water heater woes—repair or replace?

408 Posts
377 Users
0 Reactions
2,228 Views
gingerc77
Posts: 10
(@gingerc77)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, agreed—once rust kicks in, you're mostly delaying the inevitable. I looked into the anode rod thing myself when mine started acting up. Seems like it can help if you catch it early enough, but once you're seeing actual rust-colored water, it's probably past that point. Ended up biting the bullet and replacing mine...figured I'd rather spend upfront than deal with a flooded laundry room later.

Reply
paulsailor
Posts: 10
(@paulsailor)
Active Member
Joined:

- Just went through this myself—rusty water, weird noises, the whole nine yards.
- Thought about the anode rod swap too, but honestly, once rust shows up, feels like putting a Band-Aid on a sinking ship.
- Ended up replacing mine last month. Wallet wasn't thrilled, but sleeping better knowing I won't wake up to an indoor swimming pool...
- On the bright side, showers have never felt better. Silver linings, right?

Reply
Posts: 7
(@anthonyevans252)
Active Member
Joined:

Went through something similar last year—rusty water, odd rumbling noises, the works. I debated the anode rod swap too, but after crunching numbers and reading way too many horror stories online, replacement seemed smarter in the long run. Definitely hurt the budget short-term, but peace of mind is worth something, right? Plus, my water bill actually dropped a bit afterward, probably because I'm not running the tap forever waiting for clear water anymore...

Glad you're enjoying the improved showers though. Sometimes it's those small comforts that help justify the expense. Hang in there, the wallet pain fades eventually.

Reply
Page 82 / 82
Share:
Scroll to Top