Tried a patch too—duct tape and prayers—but that was just wishful thinking.
That’s a classic move, but yeah, once you see rust in the water, it’s usually a sign the tank’s corroded from the inside out. At that point, even swapping the anode or flushing won’t buy much time. If anyone’s still on the fence, here’s a quick rundown: 1) Check for leaks or rust at the base. 2) Test the pressure relief valve. 3) If you’re seeing rusty water, replacement’s the safest bet. I’ve seen folks try epoxy patches, but honestly, those are just temporary band-aids. Better to bite the bullet before you’re mopping up gallons of water.
I’ve seen folks try epoxy patches, but honestly, those are just temporary band-aids.
Agreed—epoxy might buy you a few weeks if you’re really in a pinch, but once that rust shows up in the water, it’s game over. I’ve tried squeezing extra life out of old tanks before... never really worth the stress.
Honestly, I’ve tried every trick in the book—epoxy, pipe clamps, you name it. If you’re seeing rust in the water, that tank’s pretty much toast. At that point, I’d rather just swap it out than risk a flood and angry tenants. It’s less hassle in the long run.
Honestly, I get the urge to patch things up and squeeze a bit more life out of them, but with rust showing up in the water? That’s a hard pass for me. I’ve tried the “quick fixes” before—slapped some epoxy on a pinhole leak once, thought I was clever... until a month later when the whole bottom gave out and I had a mini swimming pool in my basement. Not worth the headache.
Once that rust is in the tank, it’s usually eating away from the inside, and there’s just no real way to stop it. A replacement might seem pricey up front, but it’s way cheaper than dealing with water damage or a full-blown emergency call at 2am. If you’re seeing rust in your hot water, that tank’s on borrowed time. Just bite the bullet and swap it out before it decides for you.
Yeah, I hear you—once rust shows up, it’s usually game over for the tank. I’ve seen folks try to stretch it out with patches and sealants, but honestly, it’s just delaying the inevitable. You’re right, a new tank costs less than a flooded basement. Good call.
