As a first-time homeowner myself, I totally get the hesitation. Have you checked the anode rod yet? Mine looked pretty rusty on the outside too, but when I pulled the rod, it was completely corroded away—basically just a wire left. Replacing that bought me some extra time. But yeah, if you're seeing rust spots externally, I'd be cautious...water damage cleanup isn't something I'd wanna repeat anytime soon. Are you comfortable checking the rod yourself, or is that beyond your comfort zone?
Checking the anode rod is solid advice, but honestly, if you're already seeing rust spots on the outside, I'd lean toward replacement. I've seen too many tanks go from "a little rusty" to indoor swimming pool overnight...not fun. Sure, swapping the rod might buy you some time, but it's probably just delaying the inevitable. If budget allows, I'd bite the bullet now and save yourself a headache later.
Have you ever tried draining a rusty tank that's been sitting too long? Trust me, it's like opening Pandora's box—rust flakes everywhere and water that looks like iced tea (but way less refreshing). Sure, you could swap the rod and cross your fingers, but how much do you really enjoy gambling with soggy carpets? If you're already seeing rust spots outside, isn't that tank basically waving a white flag at you already? Might be time to retire it gracefully before it retires itself...
"Might be time to retire it gracefully before it retires itself..."
Yeah, learned that lesson the hard way myself. Thought I'd squeeze another year out of mine—ended up with a mini flood and ruined flooring. Better to bite the bullet early than deal with cleanup later...
If you're seeing rust already, it's usually a sign the tank's lining is compromised. You could try flushing it out first—turn off power/gas, hook up a hose to the drain valve, and let it run clear—but honestly, that's probably just buying you a little time. Once corrosion sets in, leaks aren't far behind. Might wanna check the anode rod too; if it's completely eaten away, that's another red flag. Better safe than sorry with water damage...
