So my bathtub stopper finally gave up on me and I'm looking at replacements. Torn between those pop-up ones and the flip-it style... pop-ups seem sleek but I've heard they clog easier? Flip-its look kinda bulky tho. Anyone got experience with either type?
I've installed both types, and honestly, pop-ups do look nicer but they're a pain when hair gets stuck. Flip-its might seem bulky, but they're way easier to clean out—less hassle overall. I'd lean toward practicality over looks any day...
Totally get what you're saying about the hair issue—pop-ups can turn into mini horror movies when it's cleaning time. But honestly, flip-its aren't exactly winning beauty contests either, and I've seen them get a bit loose over time. One trick I've found helpful is installing a simple mesh hair catcher under a pop-up stopper. Keeps things tidy without sacrificing looks, and cleaning becomes way less traumatic...just my two cents from the trenches of plumbing adventures.
Yeah, mesh catchers under pop-ups are a solid idea—definitely cuts down on the gross factor. But just a heads-up, I've seen those mesh screens get clogged pretty fast too. Regular checks keep things running smoothly and prevent any surprise backups later on...speaking from experience here.
