Metal tags are definitely the way to go if you want something that’ll last, especially in basements or crawl spaces where moisture’s a constant headache. Paint just flakes off after a season or two—seen it happen plenty. Heat-shrink tubing’s decent, but I’ve had it get brittle and crack over time, especially near hot water lines. Ever tried engraved plastic tags? They’re not as tough as metal, but they hold up better than paint and don’t corrode. Just depends how much you want to mess with it down the line...
They’re not as tough as metal, but they hold up better than paint and don’t corrode.
I’ve tried those engraved plastic tags under the kitchen sink, but in my crawlspace they started to curl up after a couple winters—guess it gets damp enough down there. Metal’s been the only thing that survives at my place. I do double check for sharp edges, though…last thing I need is to slice a finger while I’m poking around looking for a shutoff.
I get where you’re coming from—metal tags definitely last, but I’ve always been a little wary about using them in spots where there’s a risk of accidental contact. I’ve actually had better luck with those flexible recycled rubber tags (the kind made from old tires). They don’t curl up like the plastic ones, and they’re soft enough that you won’t get cut if you brush past them. Not as common as metal or plastic, but I found a pack online a couple years ago and they’re still holding up under my house. No rust, no sharp edges, and they seem to shrug off the damp.
Might not be everyone’s cup of tea, but if you’re looking for something that won’t corrode or slice your hand open, it’s worth a shot. Plus, feels good to reuse materials that would otherwise end up in a landfill.
Never thought about using recycled rubber tags, honestly. Do they hold ink or marker well? I’ve had plastic ones fade out on me after a year under the crawlspace, so I’m a bit skeptical. But hey, if they don’t rust or slice you up, that’s a win. Just curious—any issues with them getting brittle over time?
I’ve actually tried those rubber tags under my rental’s crawlspace. Sharpie held up better than I expected—definitely outlasted the cheap plastic ones I used before. Haven’t noticed brittleness yet, but it’s only been about two years. Anyone else had them crack in colder climates?
