I’ve wondered about overtightening too—seems like there’s a fine line between “snug” and “cracked.”
Totally get what you mean. That “snug” vs “cracked” line is like walking a tightrope with slippery socks.
- Push-fits are honestly a game changer for me. No more white-knuckle moments with the wrench.
- Haven’t had one fail yet, even after a couple years. I still check them every now and then, just in case.
- Peace of mind? Yeah, but also less swearing under the sink.
If you’re nervous, maybe try one on a less critical spot first. Worst case, you get some practice and a story for the next family BBQ.
I get the appeal of push-fits—less hassle, quicker install. But I’ve actually seen one leak after a year, right where it wasn’t supposed to budge. Maybe it was user error, maybe bad luck, but it made me a little more cautious.
-
I still kind of trust threaded connections more for anything behind a wall or somewhere tough to access.No more white-knuckle moments with the wrench.
- Push-fits are great for quick fixes or temporary setups, but for peace of mind long-term? I’m not totally sold yet.
Curious if anyone else has had one fail unexpectedly...
I’ve seen push-fits go both ways. One time, a SharkBite fitting saved me during a midnight emergency, but I’ve also had one start weeping behind a cabinet after a few months. For anything hidden or hard to reach, I’d rather sweat or thread it, even if it takes longer. Just feels safer knowing it’s not relying on an O-ring alone.
Yeah, I get what you mean about the O-ring thing. SharkBites are a lifesaver in a pinch, but I don’t trust ’em long-term where I can’t keep an eye on them. I had one tucked under a bathroom sink that started leaking, and I only caught it because the cabinet floor started warping. If I’ve got the time and space, I’ll sweat the joint every time. Just less to worry about down the road.
SharkBites are a lifesaver in a pinch, but I don’t trust ’em long-term where I can’t keep an eye on them.
Right there with you. SharkBites are like duct tape for plumbing—great when you’re in a jam, but I wouldn’t bet the farm on ’em for anything hidden. Had one behind a wall once (not my choice) and sure enough, slow leak months later. If I can swing it, torch and solder every time. Peace of mind’s worth the extra sweat.
