"Peace of mind beats surprise plumbing adventures any day."
Couldn't agree more with this. Compression fittings are handy, but I always wonder about their longevity, especially in hidden spots. I've had decent luck myself, but a buddy of mine had one pop loose behind his kitchen cabinets—didn't notice until the floor started warping. Made me rethink using them in places I can't easily check. Soldering might be a bit more hassle upfront, but at least you sleep easier knowing it's solid.
Compression fittings do get a bad rap sometimes, but honestly, when installed correctly, they're pretty reliable. I've seen solder joints fail too—usually from rushed prep or overheating the pipe. It's less about the fitting type and more about proper installation technique. If you're worried about hidden spots, maybe consider push-fit connectors? They're quick, solid, and I've rarely had callbacks on them. Plus, no torch needed...so your eyebrows stay safe.
"It's less about the fitting type and more about proper installation technique."
Couldn't agree more with this. I've had compression fittings last decades without issue, but I've also seen push-fit connectors leak after just a couple of years—usually due to rushed installs or not deburring properly. Honestly, every fitting has its quirks. Curious though...have you found push-fits hold up well long-term in hot water lines? I've always been a bit hesitant there, maybe just old habits die hard (and yes, my eyebrows have stories too...).
I'm right with you on the push-fit hesitation, especially for hot water lines. I've heard mixed experiences—some folks swear by them, others have had issues after a few years. Personally, I stick with compression fittings there...just feels safer somehow. Glad to hear your install went smoothly, though. Always satisfying when those pipes finally quiet down—peace of mind is priceless.
Totally get your caution with push-fits for hot water—I’ve been down that road myself. Had one tenant call me at midnight once because a push-fit decided to give up the ghost after just three years. Not fun, let me tell you. Compression fittings have always felt more solid to me too, but lately I've been hearing good things about some of the newer push-fit brands. Makes me wonder if they've stepped up their game or if it's just marketing hype.
Glad your install quieted things down though. Nothing beats that moment when you realize the pipes aren't banging around anymore and you can finally relax...for a while anyway. Curious if anyone’s had long-term luck with push-fits on hot lines—maybe I'm just stuck in my ways?
