Notifications
Clear all

green plumbing showdown: greywater recycling vs rainwater harvesting

641 Posts
583 Users
0 Reactions
7,229 Views
rockyyoung700
Posts: 11
(@rockyyoung700)
Active Member
Joined:

Just bought our first place and I'm leaning towards rain barrels, but this makes greywater sound pretty doable. Maybe I'll start small—laundry water seems manageable. Pumps and filters sound like a headache I'd rather avoid...


Reply
Posts: 6
(@ocean268)
Active Member
Joined:

Laundry greywater's a solid start—did that myself a few years back and it's been pretty low-maintenance. But have you thought about soaps yet? Switching detergents was a bigger hassle for me than the plumbing itself...


Reply
Posts: 4
(@crafts_ben)
New Member
Joined:

"Switching detergents was a bigger hassle for me than the plumbing itself..."

Yeah, that's exactly what's kept me hesitant about greywater setups. I've heard some of the eco-friendly detergents don't clean as well or leave clothes feeling stiff. Did you find one that actually works decently, or did you just get used to the trade-off? Also curious if anyone's tried rainwater harvesting instead—seems like less hassle with soaps, but maybe more complicated plumbing-wise...


Reply
minimalism458
Posts: 8
(@minimalism458)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, that's exactly what's kept me hesitant about greywater setups.

I've installed a few greywater systems and personally tried one at home. Honestly, the detergent switch wasn't as bad as some folks make it sound. True, some eco-brands leave clothes a bit stiff, but I found one labeled "greywater safe" that cleans pretty decently. The real hassle for me was training my family to stop using fabric softeners and bleach... Rainwater harvesting is great too, but from experience, it's definitely more involved plumbing-wise—filters, storage tanks, overflow setups—worth it, though, if you're up for the initial effort.


Reply
geek859
Posts: 9
(@geek859)
Active Member
Joined:

I totally get the hesitation around greywater systems, especially when it comes to detergents and changing family habits. We installed one at my parents' place last summer, and convincing my dad to give up his beloved fabric softener was like negotiating a peace treaty—lots of grumbling involved, haha. But honestly, after a few laundry cycles, even he admitted the clothes weren't as scratchy as he'd feared. It's mostly just about finding the right eco-friendly detergent brand that suits your water type and fabrics.

Rainwater harvesting is definitely more involved, plumbing-wise. I've assisted with a couple of installations during my apprenticeship, and yeah, it's more upfront work—especially dealing with overflow valves and filters. But once it's all set up, maintenance isn't too bad. Just gotta check your filters every now and then, especially if you're in an area with lots of leaf litter or pollen.

One thing I'd suggest for anyone considering either system: start small. Maybe try diverting greywater just from showers or sinks first rather than jumping straight into laundry—less detergent drama that way. Or if you're leaning towards rainwater harvesting, maybe start with a smaller tank setup for garden watering before scaling up to indoor plumbing.

Either way, the initial effort pays off in the long run—lower bills, less strain on municipal systems, and the satisfaction of knowing you're doing something positive for the environment. Plus, you get bragging rights among your friends about how eco-savvy you are... always a bonus!


Reply
Page 61 / 129
Share:
Scroll to Top