Manual shutoff all the way for me, but I do like having a leak sensor under the sink just in case. My “system” is basically: 1) get alert, 2) run downstairs, 3) twist valve, 4) hope it’s not stuck. Not fancy, but it works.
I get the appeal of keeping it simple, but I’m always nervous the manual shutoff will seize up when I actually need it. Ever had it stick on you? I’ve considered those auto-shutoff valves, but I’m not sure they’re worth the cost or if they’re just another thing to break.
Manual shutoffs can get cranky—mine needed a little WD-40 last year just to budge. I get the worry about auto-shutoffs, though. More tech, more things that can go haywire, right? Ever tried just exercising the valve every few months? Wondering if that helps long-term or if it’s just wishful thinking...
Ever tried just exercising the valve every few months? Wondering if that helps long-term or if it’s just wishful thinking...
I’ve actually made a habit of turning all my shutoff valves a couple times a year—kitchen, bathrooms, even the main. It’s not a magic fix, but it does seem to keep them from seizing up completely. Had one under the sink that was basically welded shut with mineral buildup before I started doing this. Took some channel locks and a lot of patience to get it moving again.
Auto-shutoffs are cool in theory, but I’m with you on the “more tech, more things that can go haywire” bit. My neighbor’s smart valve went offline during a power outage and wouldn’t reset for hours. Manual might be old school, but at least you know what you’re dealing with.
WD-40 helps in a pinch, but I’ve found plumber’s grease works better long-term—less gunky. Just gotta remember to wipe off any excess so it doesn’t attract dust.
Manual might be old school, but at least you know what you’re dealing with.
Couldn’t agree more. I’ve got a couple older buildings and those “old school” valves are still kicking, mostly because I give them a little twist every now and then. Tried one of those smart leak detectors once—thing chirped at 2am for no reason and nearly gave me a heart attack. Give me a wrench and some plumber’s grease any day. Tech is great until it isn’t, especially when tenants are calling about water everywhere...