Been using a steel pipe wrench for years now, and it's been solid—heavy, yeah, but gets the job done. Recently borrowed my buddy's aluminum one and man, it felt like night and day. Way lighter, easier on the wrists, but I'm kinda skeptical about durability long-term. Anyone here switched from steel to aluminum or vice versa? Curious if the lighter weight holds up over time or if steel is still king.
I've used both steel and aluminum pipe wrenches over the years, and honestly, aluminum holds up better than you'd think. Sure, steel feels indestructible, but unless you're really abusing the thing, aluminum wrenches can last a long time. I switched to aluminum about five years ago—my wrists thanked me—and it's still going strong. Only downside is aluminum jaws can wear a bit quicker, but replacements are cheap and easy to find. Might be worth giving it a shot.
I've been using aluminum wrenches for years now, and honestly, they're a lifesaver on long plumbing days. Sure, steel feels tougher, but unless you're hammering nails with it (please don't...), aluminum holds up just fine. My wrists definitely appreciate the lighter weight.
